Carve-Out Guaranty
A carve-out guaranty is a guaranty on a non-recourse loan under which the sponsor becomes personally liable only if the borrower or the sponsor commits specific bad acts listed in the loan documents.
What does a carve-out guaranty contain?
There is no formula for a carve-out guaranty. It contains a list of acts in two groups, and the liability differs:
- Loss carve-outs: the guarantor pays the lender's actual loss caused by the act. Common examples are fraud or misrepresentation, misapplication of rents, insurance proceeds or security deposits, physical waste, and failure to pay property taxes or insurance when the property's income was enough to pay them.
- Full recourse carve-outs, sometimes called springing recourse: the whole loan becomes recourse to the guarantor. Common triggers are a voluntary bankruptcy filing by the borrower, collusion in an involuntary filing, and an unpermitted transfer of the property or of control of the borrower.
Many carve-out guaranties are paired with an environmental indemnity, which survives repayment of the loan.
How did the carve-out guaranty work on the sample bridge loan?
Illustrative figures. Before the $9.0 million refinance, the sponsor's 96-unit renovation was financed with a non-recourse bridge loan with a $7,889,000 commitment, and the sponsor signed a carve-out guaranty. Funded balance after the interest reserve: $7,886,930. Monthly interest after that: $59,152.
| Event | Type | Guarantor liability |
|---|---|---|
| Property manager collects a month of rent and the borrower uses it to pay another property's bills instead of the $59,152 interest payment | Loss carve-out (misapplication of rents) | The loss caused, up to the misapplied amount |
| Borrower files a voluntary bankruptcy petition | Full recourse carve-out | The full balance, $7,886,930, plus interest and costs |
| Renovation runs late and the property is sold after default for less than the balance | No carve-out triggered | None; the loss stays with the lender |
When the property stabilized, the $9,000,000 bank refinance replaced this structure with full recourse and a payment guaranty from the same sponsor.
How do lenders use carve-out guaranties?
Carve-outs keep the sponsor's incentives aligned during a workout: a sponsor who files the borrower into bankruptcy to delay foreclosure, or diverts rents while the loan is in default, puts its own balance sheet at risk. A lender relying on a carve-out guaranty still underwrites the guarantor, because a springing recourse trigger is worth only what the guarantor can pay.
Typical policy treatment (illustrative): the sample bridge lender requires a carve-out guaranty and an environmental indemnity on every non-recourse loan, and tests the guarantor's net worth and liquidity at closing as it would for a payment guaranty.
What are common carve-out mistakes?
- Describing a carve-out guaranty as recourse when no trigger has occurred.
- Not underwriting the carve-out guarantor because the loan is non-recourse.
- Missing a negotiated change that narrows a carve-out, for example limiting bankruptcy recourse to a capped amount.
- Overlooking that a sponsor's carve-out guaranties on other loans are contingent liabilities.
Where does the carve-out guaranty appear in the credit memo?
The loan terms section lists the guarantor, the carve-out categories and any caps. The guarantor section tests net worth and liquidity, and the sponsor's other guaranties appear with contingent liabilities, drawn from the schedule of real estate owned.
Related terms
Recourse and non-recourse, bridge loan, sponsor analysis, schedule of real estate owned, cash management and lockbox.
Where LenderBox does this work
Through global cash flow analysis, LenderBox brings the borrower, guarantors and related entities into one view, with each figure cited to the return or statement it came from, so your team can underwrite a carve-out guarantor with its other obligations in view.