Contingent Liabilities
Contingent liabilities are obligations a borrower or guarantor may have to pay if another party fails, most often guaranties of other loans, and they reduce the real support a guarantor offers.
How are contingent liabilities measured?
Total contingent liabilities = sum of guaranteed balances (or, more conservatively, guaranteed commitments including unused lines) + other contingent obligations
- Guaranties of the borrower and its affiliates: debts already in the lender's analysis of the relationship.
- Guaranties of outside debt: loans to unrelated entities that could become the guarantor's to pay.
- Other contingent obligations: letters of credit, pending litigation, joint and several obligations under partnership agreements and unfunded capital commitments.
- Balance or commitment basis: the balance shows today's exposure; the commitment shows the most it could become.
What are the contingent liabilities on a sample C&I deal?
Illustrative figures. Owner A and Owner B each guarantee, jointly and severally, all debt of Sample Fabrication, Inc. and Sample Realty's mortgage.
| Guaranteed obligation | Each owner |
|---|---|
| Sample Fabrication debt, pro forma ($1,700,000 existing + $1,200,000 proposed) | $2,900,000 |
| Sample Realty mortgage | $1,800,000 |
| Total on balances | $4,700,000 |
| Plus the unused revolver commitment | $600,000 |
| Total on commitments | $5,300,000 |
Before the new loan the total on balances was $3,500,000. These debts are already in the $823,872 of global debt service, so they are not added again. Owner A also guarantees a $250,000 loan to an unrelated partnership, with $30,000 of annual debt service currently paid by that partnership, bringing Owner A's total to $4,950,000 on balances. If Owner A had to make those payments, global debt service would rise to $853,872 and global DSCR would fall from 1.56x to 1.51x.
How do lenders use contingent liabilities?
Joint and several guaranties mean each owner is liable for the full amount, so Owner B's $710,000 of net worth outside the businesses stands behind $4,700,000 of guaranteed debt, not a 40% share of it. Outside guaranties compete for the same liquidity. Many lenders list each contingent liability with its status, test the guarantor's capacity if the largest outside guaranty were called, and compare the list with the guarantor's credit report and tax returns.
Illustrative policy treatment: every guaranty listed with its balance and status, debt already in global debt service not added again, and a sensitivity that assumes the largest outside guaranty is called.
Where does contingent liability analysis go wrong?
- Adding guaranties of the borrower's own debt to global debt service a second time.
- Leaving outside guaranties out entirely because the other borrower is paying today.
- Counting a joint and several guaranty at the owner's percentage instead of the full amount.
- Using balances when an unused line could be drawn before the guaranty is called.
- Accepting a personal financial statement with no contingent liabilities listed when the tax return shows other entities with debt.
Where do contingent liabilities appear in the credit memo?
They appear in the guarantor section as a schedule of each guaranty, its balance, its payment status and whether its debt service is already in the global DSCR, with a sensitivity for outside guaranties.
Related terms
Personal financial statement, guarantor liquidity, global DSCR, global cash flow, sponsor analysis.
Where LenderBox does this work
Through global cash flow analysis, LenderBox brings the borrower, its guarantors and their related entities into one view, so the owners' other entities and guaranties are on the record before you commit.