Maturity Risk
Maturity risk is the risk that a borrower cannot repay or refinance the balance still owed when a loan’s term ends, usually a balloon payment left because the amortization period is longer than the term.
What are the maturity risk formulas?
Balloon = loan balance remaining after the last scheduled payment of the term
Largest refinance loan = (projected NOI / required DSCR) / annual loan constant at the refinance rate
Loan to value at maturity = balloon / (projected NOI / exit cap rate)
Debt yield at maturity = projected NOI / balloon
NOI needed to refinance = balloon x annual loan constant at the refinance rate x required DSCR
- Projected NOI: NOI at maturity, usually held flat or stressed.
- Required DSCR: the coverage a new lender would require.
- Annual loan constant: twelve monthly payments on a $1 loan at the assumed rate and amortization.
- Exit cap rate: the capitalization rate assumed at maturity, usually above today's.
The loan passes when the largest refinance loan is at least the balloon. Prudent tests hold NOI flat or stress it, and assume a higher rate and cap rate than today.
How does the sample deal look at maturity?
Illustrative figures. The 96-unit community's $9,000,000 loan is at 6.25 percent, 30-year amortization, 10-year term. After 120 payments the balloon is $7,581,393.77. Test assumptions: NOI flat at $871,000, refinance rate 7.25 percent on a 30-year amortization (an 8.19 percent constant), 1.25x DSCR, exit cap rate 7.5 percent.
- Largest new loan: $871,000 / 1.25 = $696,800 of debt service, and $696,800 / 8.19% = $8,511,974, above the balloon
- Value at maturity: $871,000 / 7.5% = $11,613,333; loan to value 65.3 percent
- Debt yield at maturity: $871,000 / $7,581,393.77 = 11.5 percent
- NOI needed to refinance the balloon at 1.25x: $7,581,393.77 x 8.19% x 1.25 = $775,777, so NOI could fall 10.9 percent and the balloon would still refinance
The constant is shown rounded; the results use the exact figure. The loan passes the test because it amortizes: the borrower repays $1,418,606.23 over the term. Had the loan been interest only, the full $9,000,000 would fall due, above the $8,511,974 the property supports at the test terms.
How do lenders use the maturity test?
A loan can perform for its whole term and still fail at maturity if rates, cap rates or the property's income have moved against it. A lender facing a balloon the property cannot refinance often has to renew or modify the loan on weaker terms, and the loan may move to a criticized rating. Testing the exit at origination shows how much room the structure leaves, and shorter amortization, a lower loan amount, or a cash sweep near maturity can add more. Many lenders also track maturities across the portfolio so refinance risk does not cluster in one year.
Typical policy treatment (illustrative): the sample lender tests the exit with NOI flat, the rate one point higher, a 1.25x DSCR and a 7.5 percent exit cap rate, and reruns the test at annual review.
What are common maturity risk mistakes?
- Testing the refinance at today's rate and cap rate.
- Assuming NOI growth that the property's history and market do not support.
- Ignoring large lease expirations scheduled just before maturity on a commercial property.
- Treating an extension option as a solution when its tests are the ones likely to fail.
Where does maturity risk appear in the credit memo?
The memo's structure or risk section shows the balloon, the refinance test with its assumptions, loan to value and debt yield at maturity, and the NOI cushion. After closing, the same test is rerun at annual review and well before maturity.
Related terms
Amortization, stress testing, debt yield, lease rollover, bridge loan.
Where LenderBox does this work
With covenant and portfolio monitoring, LenderBox keeps covenants, key dates and annual reviews in view for the life of the loan, so the maturity your team must refinance is on the calendar well before it arrives.