Appraisal report · Loan documents

Weigh each appraisal against the T-12 and the market.

Value is tested twice in LenderBox's appraisal review: the appraiser's income against the T-12 and the rent roll, and the value and cap rate against the market. Your reviewer sees every gap with its page, and committee weighs a value it can test, beside the largest loan the deal supports.

APPRAISAL · ILLUSTRATIVEEFFECTIVE 09/15/2026 · 96 UNITS
The income approach and the reconciliation, as delivered
APPRAISAL REPORT · 96-UNIT APARTMENT COMMUNITY · PAGES 41 AND 55
LINEAPPRAISER
PAGE 41 · INCOME APPROACH, DIRECT CAPITALIZATION
Potential gross rent1,486,000
2Less vacancy and credit loss, 5.0%(74,300)
Plus other income58,000
Effective gross income1,469,700
Less operating expenses(594,700)
1Net operating income875,000
3Capitalization rate7.00%
4Indicated value, income approach12,500,000
5Market rent growth, forecast4.0% a year
PAGE 55 · RECONCILIATION
Sales comparison approach12,700,000
Cost approachNot developed
4Market value, as is12,500,000
Market value, as stabilized12,500,000
Extraordinary assumptionsNone
READ FROM THIS DOCUMENT, EACH FIGURE CITED
1Appraiser's NOI$875,000Appraisal, p. 41
2Vacancy and credit loss5.0%Appraisal, p. 41
3Capitalization rate7.0%Appraisal, p. 41
4Value, as is and stabilized$12,500,000Appraisal, pp. 41 and 55
5Forecast rent growth4% a yearAppraisal, p. 41
Rent growth above the market4%
The appraiser grows rents 4% a year, above the market around the property. Underwriting holds NOI at the T-12's $871,000, a 6.97% cap rate on the appraised value.
Appraisal, p. 41Market dataT-12, p. 3
What a credit officer checks on an appraisal

Questions to put to the appraiser before value counts.

Each check sets the appraisal beside the T-12, the rent roll, the market or your policy. The results come from the illustrative 96-unit refinance; market figures are marked as market data from third-party data providers.

THE CHECKON THE SAMPLE FILE · ILLUSTRATIVE
Approaches and reconciliation
Which approaches the appraiser developed, how far apart they land, and which one the final value rests on.
TIES OUT
Income approach $12,500,000 and sales comparison $12,700,000, 1.6% apart. The cost approach was not developed, as is usual for a stabilized apartment property bought and sold on its income. The value is reconciled to the income approach.
Appraisal, pp. 41, 52 and 55
The appraiser's NOI against the T-12
Income, vacancy and expenses in the direct capitalization, set beside what the property actually earned.
ON THE RECORD
$875,000 against $871,000. The appraiser uses 5.0% vacancy where the T-12 lost 6.0%, worth $14,700, and $10,700 more in expenses. Underwriting keeps $871,000.
Appraisal, p. 41T-12, p. 3
Cap rate and comparable sales against the market
The appraiser's rate and comparables, set beside market data for similar properties.
TIES OUT
Four comparable sales at 6.8% to 7.2% bracket the 7.0% rate, and the rate is in line with the market around the property.
Appraisal, p. 52Market data
Forecast assumptions
Rent growth and vacancy in the forecast, set beside the market.
FLAGGED
Rents grow 4% a year in the forecast, above the market around the property. The value capitalizes today's income, so underwriting holds NOI at the T-12 and sizes on it.
Appraisal, p. 41Market data
As is, as stabilized and extraordinary assumptions
Which value the loan is sized on, and any assumption or hypothetical condition that value depends on.
TIES OUT
Both values are $12,500,000, because the property is stabilized at 94.8% occupancy. The report states no extraordinary assumption or hypothetical condition.
Appraisal, pp. 3 and 55Rent roll, p. 2
Effective date and loan to value
How old the value is against the rest of the file, and what it supports under your policy.
TIES OUT
$9,000,000 is 72.0% of value against your 75% limit, which alone would allow $9,375,000. The value is effective 09/15/2026, 15 days before the rent roll date.
Appraisal, p. 3Rent roll, p. 2Policy
What LenderBox returns

A $12.5 million value, weighed against the market and the T-12.

The appraisal arrives cited, beside the property's own results and its market, with the largest loan the deal supports.

CITED TO THE PAGEEvery figure from the appraisal is cited to its document and page, and market figures are marked as market data from third-party data providers.
BESIDE ITS MARKETThe appraised value and capitalization rate are set beside the market around the property, and committee sees the comparison.
THE FIGURES THAT MOVE A RATIOYour analyst confirms the figures that move a ratio or a policy test, not every field in a long appraisal.
THE LARGEST LOAN, AND WHAT SETS ITSee the largest loan the deal supports and the limit that sets it, so the counteroffer is ready before the borrower asks.
See the full market view →
WHERE THE FIGURES GO · ILLUSTRATIVESAME SAMPLE FILE
Value into sizing, market view and memo
LOAN TO VALUE72.0% against your 75% limit
Appraisal, p. 55
MAXIMUM SUPPORTABLE LOAN$9,252,146, set by the stress test; value alone allows $9,375,000
MARKET VIEWCap rate in line; rent growth above the market, flagged
Appraisal, p. 41Market data
CREDIT MEMOCollateral section drafted with value, cap rate and the flag, each figure cited

Value, cap rate and comparables, with the weighting left to you.

Reading the report
LENDERBOX DOESReads the income approach, the comparable sales and the reconciliation, and cites each figure to its page.
STAYS WITH YOUR TEAMWhether the appraisal meets your institution's requirements and review standards.
Against the T-12
LENDERBOX DOESSets the appraiser's income, vacancy and expenses beside the operating statement.
STAYS WITH YOUR TEAMWhich NOI the loan is sized on.
Against the market
LENDERBOX DOESSets the cap rate, the comparables and rent growth beside market data, marked as market data.
STAYS WITH YOUR TEAMHow much weight the appraisal deserves.
Sizing
LENDERBOX DOESShows loan to value and the largest loan the deal supports, with the limit that sets it.
STAYS WITH YOUR TEAMThe loan amount and the structure you offer.
The memo
LENDERBOX DOESDrafts value, cap rate and the rent growth flag into the memo.
STAYS WITH YOUR TEAMWhether $12.5 million is the right value.

An appraised value the loan keeps using for years.

01 · FIRST LOOKThe offering memo returns policy flags and a first sizing on the broker's figures before the appraisal is ordered.
02 · UNDERWRITING · THIS DOCUMENTThe appraisal is read beside the T-12, the rent roll and the market.
03 · CREDIT DECISION · THIS DOCUMENTCommittee sees value, cap rate, loan to value and the appraisal's flag, each figure cited.
04 · CLOSINGConditions tied to the value clear before closing.
05 · LIFE OF THE LOANAt each annual review, new financials are set beside the original underwriting, every figure cited, with covenant monitoring on the loan.

Appraisal questions before the value counts

Which parts of an appraisal are read and cited?

The income approach, the sales comparison, the reconciliation and the assumptions: NOI, vacancy, expenses, cap rate, comparable sales, value as is and as stabilized, and the effective date. Each figure is cited to its page.

Which NOI does the loan get sized on?

Your underwriter decides. The appraiser's income and expenses are set beside the operating statement; on the sample, the appraiser's $875,000 sits beside the T-12's $871,000, both with their pages.

Does LenderBox compare the appraisal with the market?

Yes. The appraised value and capitalization rate are set beside the market around the property, and committee sees the comparison. Market figures come from third-party data providers and are marked as market data.

Who decides if the appraisal passes?

Your reviewer, who also decides how much weight it deserves. LenderBox hands the reviewer every figure with its page, and every gap against the file and the market.

What happens when the appraiser's rent growth beats the market?

It is flagged against third-party market data. On the sample, the cap rate is in line while rent growth runs ahead.

Bring the appraisal with the rent growth you doubt.

Bring the appraisal, the T-12 and the rent roll. The demo can run on your own deal documents, with each value and cap rate returned beside its page.

Bring a deal
30 MINUTES. NO COMMITMENT. 90-DAY MONEY-BACK GUARANTEE.
Not ready to talk? See pricing