Annual Review

An annual review is the yearly re-underwriting of an existing commercial loan on updated financial statements, tax returns and guarantor information to confirm the risk rating, covenant compliance, collateral and repayment capacity.

Formula

What does a credit officer check in an annual review?

There is no formula for an annual review. It reruns the underwriting in order: updated spread, coverage and debt ratios, covenant results and headroom, global cash flow and guarantors, collateral and borrowing base, then the risk rating. What a credit officer checks:

  • Updated financials: the borrower's year-end statements and returns, related entities' returns and guarantors' personal financial statements.
  • Performance against the underwriting case: whether results matched what the approval assumed.
  • Compliance history: each compliance certificate, borrowing base certificate and reporting deadline during the year.
  • Rating: confirmed or changed, with the reason.

What does an annual review find on a sample C&I deal?

Illustrative figures. Suppose that in the first year after closing, Sample Fabrication, Inc.'s adjusted EBITDA falls 10%, from $1,310,000 to $1,179,000, with everything else unchanged.

TestAt approval (pro forma)At reviewRequirement
Fixed charge coverage1.47x1.23x ($679,000 / $550,872)at least 1.20x
Global DSCR1.56x1.40x ($1,156,000 / $823,872)at least 1.25x
Fixed charge headroom$148,954$17,954

Both tests still pass. The review would note that fixed charge coverage is now close to the covenant, ask the borrower for the cause (volume, margin or cost) and for current interim results, and consider whether the grade 4 rating still fits or whether closer monitoring is warranted. It would also confirm that Customer 1's share of revenue and the guarantors' $620,000 of liquidity have not moved against the lender.

How do lenders use the annual review?

Loans are approved on a forecast. The annual review checks the forecast against what happened and catches a weakening credit while there is still time to restructure, add collateral or reprice. It keeps the risk rating accurate, which feeds the allowance for credit losses and portfolio reporting. Many lenders require an annual review for commercial relationships above a policy threshold, with the scope scaled to size and risk, and examiners commonly sample them.

Illustrative policy treatment: a full review for every commercial relationship above a set exposure, completed within a set period after year-end statements arrive.

Where do annual reviews go wrong?

  • Updating the spread without comparing results with the approval case.
  • Confirming the rating by default when coverage or headroom has narrowed.
  • Skipping the guarantor update, so a new outside guaranty or lost liquidity goes unseen.
  • Completing the review months after statements arrive, when the information is stale.
  • Testing covenants on the memo's definitions instead of the loan agreement's.

Where does the annual review sit in the credit file?

The review is its own memo, shorter than the approval memo, with the updated ratio summary, covenant table, global cash flow, rating rationale and any actions required. It sits beside the original credit memo in the file.

Related terms

Risk rating, compliance certificate, covenant headroom, financial spreading, examiner-ready documentation.

Where LenderBox does this work

With covenant and portfolio monitoring, LenderBox keeps covenants, key dates and annual reviews in view for the life of the loan, so the loan that needs attention surfaces first.

See it worked on a deal you bring.

A 30-minute demo can run on documents you bring: LenderBox reads the file, shows the source page behind each figure, and checks the result against your credit policy.

See it on your deal
30 MINUTES. NO COMMITMENT. 90-DAY MONEY-BACK GUARANTEE.