Risk Rating
A risk rating is the grade a lender assigns to a loan or borrower on its internal scale to express the likelihood of repayment as agreed, set at approval and updated whenever the borrower’s condition changes.
What does a credit officer check to assign a risk rating?
There is no formula for a risk rating. The grade is the one whose written definition best fits the borrower's repayment capacity, financial strength, collateral, guarantor support and trends, and any override of a scorecard result is explained. What a credit officer checks:
- Scale: most lenders use a numbered scale with several pass grades and then the supervisory categories of special mention, substandard, doubtful and loss.
- Grade definitions: written in the credit policy, often with ranges for coverage, debt and liquidity at each pass grade.
- Scorecard: some lenders calculate a starting grade from weighted factors and let the officer adjust it with a written reason.
- Special mention and below: special mention marks potential weaknesses that deserve close attention; substandard, doubtful and loss mark well-defined weaknesses of increasing severity.
How is a sample C&I deal rated?
Illustrative only. The lender uses a nine-grade scale: grades 1 to 5 pass, 6 special mention, 7 substandard, 8 doubtful, 9 loss. The proposed grade for Sample Fabrication, Inc. is 4.
| Factor | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Repayment capacity | Pro forma fixed charge coverage 1.47x; global DSCR 1.56x |
| Debt | Funded debt to EBITDA 2.21x pro forma; total liabilities to tangible net worth 1.25x |
| Liquidity | Current ratio 1.46x; $600,000 of revolver availability; guarantor liquidity $620,000 |
| Weakness | Largest customer 28.0% of revenue, outside policy; covenant headroom of 11.4% on fixed charge coverage |
| Stress | A 10% fall in adjusted EBITDA leaves fixed charge coverage at 1.23x and global DSCR at 1.40x |
The strengths support a pass grade; the concentration and the narrow fixed charge cushion keep it out of the stronger pass grades (1 to 3). The memo would also state what would move it: a fixed charge coverage result below the 1.20x covenant, or the loss of Customer 1, would put a downgrade under consideration.
How do lenders use risk ratings?
The rating drives how often a loan is reviewed, which approval authority applies to changes, pricing in many institutions, the allowance for credit losses and what management and examiners see in portfolio reports. A rating that is not updated when results weaken hides risk from all of them. Illustrative policy treatment: the nine-grade scale above, with the grade confirmed at each annual review and reconsidered whenever a covenant fails or a payment is late.
Where do risk ratings go wrong?
- Leaving a rating unchanged after a covenant breach or a waiver.
- Rating on the guarantor's strength alone when the business cannot repay from its own cash flow.
- Assigning a grade without tying it to the written grade definitions.
- Overriding a scorecard upward without a documented reason.
- Inconsistent grades for similar borrowers across officers or branches.
Where does the risk rating appear in the credit memo?
It appears in the summary at the front, with a rationale section that ties the grade to the policy definitions and lists the triggers for a change.
Related terms
Annual review, credit box, covenant headroom, stress testing, credit memo.
Where LenderBox does this work
LenderBox drafts the credit memo and recommendation with every figure cited to its page, so the officer who assigns the grade works from one checked set of numbers.